Review
AI summary based on real user insights
Among users who weighed their options in the Guard lineup, many came down firmly in favor of the S1 Electro, noting you can never have too much power. For those dealing with carpeted floors in particular, it stands out as the only one suitable for carpet in its class, and reviewers generally agree that Miele will have better pick up compared to competing brands.
That said, the S1 Electro is not without its frustrations. A recurring complaint is that the hose is constantly fouling the attachments, sometimes requiring users to resort to tipping the vacuum on its side to manage it. Users also note that the Guard series reduced suction settings from 6 to only 4, and the angle of the nozzle is just so much smaller than expected, which some find limiting. Worth noting too is that the Guard S1 does not support a motorized power nozzle, a caveat that could matter for heavy-duty carpet cleaning needs.
On the practical side, the S1 Electro carries a changed bag system compared to older Miele models, and prospective buyers should be aware that 3rd party bags are so much more expensive, which can add up over time. Specs-wise, it operates at a noise level of 78 dB(A) with a 10m operating radius and a weight of 5.7 kg, making it a moderately substantial machine.
From a value standpoint, at least one buyer reported getting almost $300 CAD back, suggesting there are meaningful savings to be found depending on where and when you purchase. As a newer but entry-level model, it sits at an accessible point in Miele's lineup, though nobody knows how long they will last given its relatively recent introduction. Some users have also remarked that the units seriously look like off-brand knock offs, which may disappoint those expecting Miele's traditionally premium aesthetic.
